Being John Malkovich (1999)

Film details

Comedy · Drama · Fantasy · Spike Jonze · 1h 53min

Synopsis

One day at work, unsuccessful puppeteer Craig finds a portal into the head of actor John Malkovich. The portal soon becomes a passion for anybody who enters its mad and controlling world of overtaking another human body.

Verdict

Normalizes lesbian relationships and presents identity as fluid and manipulable.

In-depth analysis

The film constructs a postmodern fable where human identity is presented as something entirely malleable and disconnected from bodily reality. The portal into Malkovich's mind is not merely a surreal device: it is the narrative vehicle to propose that the self can be anything, even another person. The central problem is not the fantastic premise, but its anthropological consequences: Lotte, the protagonist's wife, discovers attraction to women precisely when she 'is' Malkovich, and the film presents this transition as an awakening of her true identity. The lesbian relationship between Lotte and Maxine is normalized as a natural part of the journey of self-discovery. Furthermore, the sex scenes between Maxine and Malkovich, knowing that Craig or Lotte are 'inside' the body, objectify human intimacy in a disturbing manner. Charlie Kaufman's screenplay is ingenious, Spike Jonze's direction is original, but the work proposes that sexual and personal identity are mere subjective constructs. It is not an honest exploration of the desire for transcendence: it is a celebration of anthropological relativism disguised as existential comedy. Not recommended.