Brokeback Mountain (2014)

Film details

Music · Jérémie Cuvillier · 2h 10min

Synopsis

A tragic and secretive romance ensues over many years after two men meet while herding sheep on Brokeback Mountain in this opera based on Annie Proulx's short story and its subsequent Oscar-winning film adaptation.

Verdict

⚠️ [IDEOLOGICAL ALERT]: Normalizes homosexual relationships as pure love repressed by society.

In-depth analysis

Brokeback Mountain portrays the intense relationship between two cowboys, Ennis and Jack, as a pure and sacred love thwarted by traditional social and moral norms. The film depicts their sexual encounters as an expression of a profound bond, blaming society for the suffering that prevents them from living together openly. This includes explicit sequences of physical intimacy between them, with movements and sounds that leave little to the imagination, though without full nudity in that act. Both marry women and have children, but their marriages disintegrate due to constant infidelity, presented not as destructive betrayal but as a consequence of unjust repression. The film highlights familial devastations, but attributes them to a lack of social acceptance, not to the disorder of choices. Ennis resists partly out of fear and cultural pressure, which the film portrays as a tragic obstacle. There is violence in brutal fights and references to hate crimes, along with abundant coarse language. Spiritually, it mentions Christian backgrounds and a wedding in a religious ceremony, but trivializes faith with jokes. While it captures human pain with masterful acting and impressive landscapes, its central message invites viewers to see homosexuality as a legitimate and heroic orientation, disregarding the natural order of family and marriage. For parents, utmost caution: it seeks to alter the perception of love, sexuality, and family, disguised as a moving drama.