God's Own Country (2017)

Film details

Romance · Drama · Francis Lee · 1h 40min

Synopsis

A young farmer in rural Yorkshire numbs his daily frustrations with binge drinking and casual sex, until the arrival of a Romanian migrant worker.

Verdict

It presents the homosexual relationship as a path to redemption and fulfillment for the protagonist.

In-depth analysis

The film deliberately constructs a narrative arc where the homosexual relationship between the protagonist and the Romanian worker is presented as the way out of Johnny's self-destruction. The screenplay establishes a contrast between the farmer's empty and alcoholic life and the supposed fulfillment he finds in intimacy with another man. The strategy is emotional: the viewer accompanies the protagonist's transformation without room to question whether that is truly the solution to his suffering. The scenes of sexual intimacy are explicit and prolonged, designed not only to show but to normalize. The austere cinematography of rural Yorkshire functions as a metaphor for the solitude that only this relationship seems able to fill. The problem is not showing a man with attraction to other men, but presenting that relationship as the redemptive climax of the story, precluding any other perspective. The R rating warns about explicit sexual content, but not about the underlying message that proposes a vision of love and intimacy contrary to human nature. Not recommended.